Ucho

Probably the best film showing the communist 1950s not as an exhilarated working class era, but as a time full of fear and widespread snitching. Brzobohatý as a high-ranking communist official and Bohadalová as his wife give the performances of a lifetime. After the Russian occupation this film went into the vaults, of course. Kachyňa made a humiliating apology and survived, but Jan Procházka, with his script, set up his professional suicide. (11.05.2003)

Kachyňa's formal austerity (changing only two locations, Illík's static camera) is a glove thrown down to the central acting tandem, who lifted it more than worthily. You don’t see this sort of riveting acting concert, based on Jan Procházka's brilliantly written book, very often. The paranoia of the times, the fickleness of the political parties of the communist regime, and last but not least the cracks of a ten-year marriage served up in one endless night. Thirty years ago, the film was an unsavory reflection of the times for the comrades, today it is an index finger raised in warning that deserves more than just a screening in club cinemas! (01.03.2007)

This story never happened. The things that really happened were much worse (as Jan Procházka noted in his screenplay). “The most banned of the banned" or another busy night for the Minister’s private secretary. A thick atmosphere hand in hand with incredible tension-rise. A psycho(logical) portrait of life in Czechoslovakia in the nineteen fifties (i.e. during the Stalinist period). Kachyňa’s best ever picture. Those are the main ingredients of the best Czechoslovak movie about the impacts of Communism on regular people. (16.03.2022)

Extraordinary film by Karel Kachyna, which the director had to iron out with the authorities for a long time, while the film went straight into the vault. Top-notch screenplay that perfectly captures the essence of the era and regime, superbly crafted atmosphere that builds up to the final scene. Excellent cast led by Brzobohatý and Bohdalová, simply unique, although somewhat oppressive experience. This is not a movie for pleasant entertainment, but rather a heavy nightmare of our recent history. Overall impression: 100%. (16.06.2006)

All kidding aside. It is indeed sympathetic that to this day Bohdalová can still bow to Procházka, but was there really only one film that was worth so much that she would throw away her entire previous career for it? The Ear soon became the reason for her varied efforts in film (since 1937) with considerable results, and she quickly turned into a stereotypical constant on the television screen. Later, she did try to return to the big screen, but the small amount from the 1990s can never make up for the wasted two decades in which she could have fully capitalized on her mature acting. Brzobohatý and Kachyňa were of course lucky in their misfortune, as they continued on much more smoothly... (07.04.2011)

One of the 1001 movies you must see before you die – I don't want to say deservedly, but certainly not by chance. If you can imagine, or at best recall from your own experience, the fear that many people felt at that time, the testimonial value of the already disturbing and brilliantly acted The Ear is indescribable. But even today's generation doesn’t need vivid memories or excessive intelligence to grasp the tremendous power, thought and bravery of Kachyna's psychologically challenging probe, which was strictly forbidden under the comrades. A film that is unforgettable, even though it is not my cup of tea. 80% (05.08.2013)

A despotic anonymous regime carried out in constant meaningless celebrations, speeches, and gestures. Its representatives, degenerated by alcohol and permanent fear. The insecurity of everyone in their current position. The personalized camera capturing the events of a party infiltrated by undercover cops, where nobody knows how to talk to whom and what is really going on, is my favorite conception of communism as totally insane chaos and generator of mental illness under the surface. (12.09.2008)

A person still has something to learn. This is definitely one of the best Czech films ever made. The story unfolds beautifully, at first it's only about two quarrelsome people who have to live together, but in the end it's about the time they live in. It's completely understandable that the film was banned. And I am immensely glad that it was preserved. A great example of biting criticism, but also excellent direction and great acting performances. (27.07.2015)